The Best Hotels for One Night in Montauk

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Perfect for a Short One-Night Stay

Located at 290 Old Montauk Highway, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa has great rooms from $773 (before taxes). It offers an outdoor pool, room service, a restaurant, a fitness center, and a bar. It has a terrific 8.10 rating out of 10 from previous guests who have stayed here. Only 2.4 miles from the city center, one-night visitors will especially love rooms with kitchens, rooms with kitchenettes, child care, pet-friendly rooms, and a hot tub at this comfortable hotel. The room service is especially nice after a long day.

Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Great for a Quick Visit to Montauk

• Family-Friendly

A great place to stay is Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina which has nice rooms starting at $880. Offering an outdoor pool, room service, a restaurant, a fitness center, and a bar, it also has a great guest rating of 8.00 out of 10 from many previous guests. It's located at 32 Star Island Road. This relaxing hotel is also nice because it offers hiking, child care, golf, pet-friendly rooms, and a game room which visitors will enjoy. Also, it's just 2.6 miles from the city center. Everyone loves a nice indoor pool, and the one here does not disappoint!

Montauk Manor

Make the Most of Your One-Night Stay Here

• Great Value: the price is lower than average for 3-star hotels.
• High Quality: guest ratings are higher than average.
• Family-Friendly
• Heated pool

We found Montauk Manor to be a great place to stay, and the price starts at $229. We loved that is has an outdoor pool, a restaurant, a fitness center, a bar, and hiking, and it also has a terrific guest rating of 8.70 out of 10 from previous guests. It's located at 236 Edgemere Street. You'll also find rooms with kitchens, rooms with kitchenettes, golf, a spa, and an indoor pool which travelers will love. And this terrific hotel is just 0.7 miles from the center of town. Make sure to set aside some time for swimming in the pool, too. It's a great value, too, because it's less than the average price for one-night trip hotels.

Sole East Beach

Perfect for a One-Day Trip to Montauk

• High Quality: guest ratings are higher than average.
• Pool

With terrific rooms from $638, Sole East Beach, at 107 South Emerson Avenue provides a pool, a restaurant, a bar, hiking, and rooms with kitchens. Its terrific guest rating is 8.30 out of 10 from previous guests staying here. Visitors will really like this convenient hotel which also offers golf, pet-friendly rooms, free parking, kids meals, and horse riding. It's located just 0.6 miles from the city center, too. Having the delicious restaurant in the hotel is an added bonus.

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

A Great Hotel for a 2-Day Trip to Montauk

• Great Value: the price is lower than average for one-night trip hotels.

Kenny's Tipperary Inn has a great guest rating of 8.10 out of 10, and offers an outdoor pool, a restaurant, scuba diving, a bar, and hiking. The great rooms here start at $181 before taxes and depending on the season. It can be found at 432 W Lake Dr. Furthermore, it also offers rooms with kitchenettes, golf, pet-friendly rooms, free parking, and mini-golf, which is nice for one-night visitors. Just 2.5 miles from the city center, this comfortable hotel is a terrific choice. Being able to prepare food in the room is also very convenient. We found the price of this hotel to be a great value because the price is less than average for one-night trip hotels.

Breakers Montauk

One of the Best Hotels for a One-Day Trip to Montauk

• Great Value: the price is lower than average for 3-star hotels.
• Heated pool

The great guest rating of Breakers Montauk is 7.75 out of 10. This place has an outdoor pool, room service, a restaurant, a bar, and rooms with kitchenettes. Prices for the terrific rooms are from $440, and it's located at 769 Old Montauk Highway. We also love the golf, free parking, kids meals, family rooms, and a heated pool which are great for visitors. And since it's just 0.5 miles from the center of the town, the location is great, too. The heated pool is comfortable, relaxing, and fun for everyone. The price of this hotel is less than average for one-night trip hotels, which makes it a great value.

Marram

A Great Hotel for Your One-Night Stay in Montauk

• Great Value: the price is lower than average for 4-star hotels.
• High Quality: guest ratings are higher than average.

A cool place is Marram because it has great rooms that start at $412. It has an outdoor pool, a restaurant, hiking, golf, and free parking, it also earned a great guest rating of 8.50 out of 10 from people who have stayed here before. It's found at 21 Surfside Place. Only 0.8 miles from the city center, travelers will especially love horse riding, laundry facilities, fishing, family rooms, and a multi-lingual staff at this terrific hotel. It's also less than the average price for one-night trip hotels, so it's a great value.

The Montauk Beach House

Perfect for a Quick Stopover in Montauk

• Great Value: the price is lower than average for 3-star hotels.
• Family-Friendly
• Heated pool

The Montauk Beach House offers an outdoor pool, a restaurant, a bar, free parking, and evening entertainment which we really like. The terrific rooms here start at $381 (before taxes). It's located at 55 South Elmwood Avenue and has earned a guest rating of 8.20/10. This convenient hotel is also nice because it offers car rentals, bicycle rental, family rooms, a heated pool, and air-conditioning which visitors will enjoy. Also, it's just 0.6 miles from the city center. It's a great value, too, because it's less than the average price for one-night trip hotels.