A Travel Price Comparison for United States of America Key West vs. New York City for Food, Nightlife, Couples, and Families

Should you visit Key West or New York City?

Which is cheaper to visit? Which is more expensive for vacation?

Should I visit Key West or New York City? This is a common question asked by many travelers. By figuring out which city has activities that align with your interests along with knowing which is more affordable, you'll understand where you can get more bang for your buck. So, let's dive into the details and the data, which all comes from actual travelers.

Key West

Key West is a quaint, laid-back, and quirky town. This is a charming small with plenty of activities, too. This is also a very beautiful destination which attracts plenty of visitors. Because of its quaint atmosphere, it draws plenty of visitors, too. Other reasons to visit include food, scuba diving and snorkeling, and beaches.

New York City

New York City is a cosmopolitan, one-of-a-kind, and vibrant city. With plenty of activities and things to do, it's a huge city that draws plenty of visitors. It's a beautiful place to visit, too. And you can't forget about the museums, theater, and nightlife.

Key West and New York City: Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Active nightlife
  • Nice resorts
  • Good scuba and snorkeling destination
  • Popular beach
  • Scenic old town
  • Family-friendly
  • Good for couples and romance
  • Impressive beauty
  • Quaint atmosphere
Things to Consider
  • Less popular for food
  • Less popular for shopping
  • Less popular with backpackers
  • Public transit not as usable
  • Less walkable
Pros
  • Popular museums and historical sights
  • Numerous theater shows
  • Popular for food and cuisine
  • Active nightlife
  • Good music scene
  • Fun shopping
  • Popular at Christmas
  • Known for Christmas markets
  • Family-friendly
  • Good for couples and romance
  • Good for backpackers and budget travelers
  • Good public transit
  • Very walkable
  • Big city activities
  • Home to the Statue of Liberty


Is there more to do in Key West or New York City?

Travelers will usually find more to do in New York City. Although Key West and New York City are popular destinations, New York City has more sights and attractions for tourists. New York City is very popular for its museums, theatre productions, food, nightlife, music, shopping, christmas markets, and big city activities, while Key West attracts visitors for its resorts, scuba diving & snorkeling, beaches, historical sights, small town charm, impressive beauty, and quaint atmosphere. Key West is famous for its festive nightlife, quirky town center, colorful personality, adrenaline-filled watersports, stunning beaches, turquoise water, and location at the southernmost point of the continental U.S. New York City is famous for its high-reaching skyscrapers, iconic landmarks, world-class theater scene, and endless energy. It is also well known for The Statue of Liberty.

How is Key West different from New York City?

Which is Better for a Holiday?

Let's take a look at the differences and similarities between New York City and Key West. Then, you can decide for yourself which place is better for your next trip.

Are the Museums and Historical Sights Better in Key West or New York City?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its sights and museums. However, Key West does not have museums and landmarks.

The museums, monuments, and landmarks in New York City are among the most recognizable in the world. The sights and museums around the city are too numerous to list, but some of the most famous include the Statue of Liberty, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Modern Art, Central Park, and the Empire State Building. This is a city that is filled with iconic landmarks and you could spend weeks here and still not see it all.

Key West does not have museums and landmarks.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Theater?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its theatre productions. However, Key West is not a theatre destination.

The theater and performance venues in New York City draw crowds from around the world. Visiting Broadway is a quintessential NYC experience. Whether you enjoy the theater or simply want to experience something new, seeing a Broadway show is a true bucket list activity.

Key West is not a theatre destination.

Is the Food Better in Key West or New York City? Which Destination has the Best Restaurants?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its local cuisine and restaurants. Also, Key West is not as famous, but is still a good town to visit for its restaurants.

For foodies, New York City is an obvious choice, as it is one of the food capitals of the world. The city has a diverse variety of restaurants, with everything from local dives to Michelin star options. There are many neighborhoods that are notable for their ethnic cuisine, particularly Little Italy and Chinatown. Quintessential NYC dishes include NYC pizza, NYC hot dogs, bagels, and Chinese dim sum.

Key West is becoming an appealing option for foodies. Head to town for local restaurants with quirky atmospheres. There are many local dishes to sample, be the town is most known for its stone crabs, conch fritters, and Mahi Mahi sandwiches. You'll also find cold drinks and waterfront dining areas.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Nightlife?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for nightlife and partying. Also, Key West is not as famous, but is still a good town to visit for its evening party scene.

New York City is a destination that you simply have to visit at least once for nightlife. Known as the city that never sleeps, you can be assured that NYC has some of the best nightlife in the world. There are world class bars and clubs, but also local venues that have a more relaxed atmosphere. Several famous clubs include Paul's Cocktail Lounge, Le Bain, and Avant Gardner.

Key West has a lively atmosphere and nightlife is popular here. This area has some of the most lively nightlife in the Florida Keys. There are quirky bars and fun hangouts where you can spend the evening. The party starts at Mallory Square around sunset and many bars stay open well into the early hours. You can also enjoy sunset cruises or pass your time at one of the many tiki bars.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Music?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its live music scene. However, Key West is not a live music destination.

Live music, and music in many other forms, is everyone in New York City Popular music venues include Music Hall of Williamsburg, Radio City Music Hall, Beacon Theatre, and Forest Hills Stadium.

Key West is not a live music destination.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Resorts?

Key West
New York City

Key West is an excellent place to visit for its luxury resorts. However, New York City is not a resort destination.

There are plenty of resorts in Key West to choose from. There are a number of high end resorts around the island, many with recognizable names such as the Hyatt and Hilton. Prices can be high, but these resorts often come with reliable luxury.

New York City is not a resort destination.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Scuba Diving and Snorkeling?

Key West
New York City

Key West is a good destination for the nearby scuba diving and snorkeling. However, New York City is not a scuba or snorkeling destination.

Grab a mask and fins and explore the underwater scenery in Key West. There are a number of dive shops and snorkeling excursions that leave from Key West. Like many tourist areas these days, the coral shows its damage from the crowds, but you'll likely see some barracuda or a Grouper.

New York City is not a scuba or snorkeling destination.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Beaches?

Key West
New York City

Key West is an excellent place to visit for its beaches. However, New York City is not a beach destination.

Many people visit Key West for it's beautiful beaches. One of the best beaches in the area is Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park. The beach has soft sand and stunning turquoise water. As is typical in the Keys, the water stays shallow for great distances.

New York City is not a beach destination.

Is Key West or New York City Better for its Old Town?

Key West
New York City

Key West is an excellent place to visit for its historic old town. However, New York City does not have a historic old town.

There are many historical things to see in the old town of Key West. The town has the most charming Old Town areas in the Florida Keys. Head to Mallory Square for the sunset street performers and explore the historic streets around Duval Street.

New York City does not have a historic old town.

Is the Shopping Better in Key West or New York City?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its shopping opportunities. However, Key West is a mediocre town for its shopping areas.

The abundance of shops in New York City make it a world-class shopping destination. The shopping is as diverse as the city itself. Head for Fifth Avenue for high end shopping or check out any of the many street markets for local items. New York is known for its many flea markets where you can find vintage items at a good price. And if you're looking to pick up a souvenir shirt or knick knack, there are plenty of souvenir shops around town as well.

Key West has some good spots for those that want to go shopping. While it definitely has its share of gimmicky souvenir shops and t-shirt stores, there are still a number of art galleries and local shops around Key West where you can enjoy shopping.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Christmas?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its Christmas activities. However, Key West does not offer Christmas activities.

New York City is a fantastic destination at Christmas. Christmas in the city is a quintessential experience. From the Christmas tree and ice skating at Rockefeller Center to seeing a live performance of the Nutcracker, everyone enjoys the holidays in New York.

Key West does not offer Christmas activities.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Christmas Markets?

Key West
New York City

New York City is notable for its Christmas markets. However, Key West does not offer Christmas markets.

New York City has a lively atmosphere around its Christmas markets. There are a number of Christmas markets that pop up around town during the holiday season. Nothing will get you more in the holiday spirit than wandering these unique venues.

Key West does not offer Christmas markets.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Families?

Key West
New York City

Kids will enjoy a visit to either Key West or New York City.

Key West is a very kid-friendly town. Families that enjoy snorkeling, aquariums, water sports, and exploring new places will enjoy visiting this part of the Florida Keys. There are many ways to get out on the water from kayaking and snorkeling to glass bottom boat tours and sunset cruises. There are also many kid-friendly beaches in the area. The town can have a party atmosphere, but it's not hard to find a more family-friendly area where everyone can have fun.

You'll find plenty of family-friendly things to do in New York City. The city has many activities for kids of all ages including world class museums, beautifully designed playgrounds, and theater shows designed just for young ones. There are many kid-friendly restaurants as well and older kids will enjoy visiting the iconic landmarks in this world-class city.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Couples?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its romantic activities. Also, Key West is not as famous, but is still a good town to visit for couples.

New York City makes for a terrific place to visit as a couple. From a beautiful carriage ride through Central Park, to a romantic river cruise at night, there is an endless list of unique activities that couples can enjoy in the city. Whether you're interested in theater, the arts, music, or nightlife, this city has it all.

Key West makes for a fun place to visit for a couple. From Mallory Square to the beautiful nearby parks, Key West makes a wonderful, romantic destination. Whether it's your honeymoon, an anniversary, or simply a couples' retreat, Key West is a great option. You can sip wine on a sunset cruise or dine at one of the many character-filled restaurants in town. If you are looking for a party, it's not hard to find, but if you want a more laid back holiday, that's also possible.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Backpackers and Budget Travelers?

Key West
New York City

New York City is notable for backpackers. However, Key West is a mediocre town for backpackers and budget travelers.

New York City is a great city to visit for backpackers. It isn't a particularly budget-friendly destination, but it does get its share of backpackers, so you'll find a nice list of hostels and affordable hangouts that are perfect for the backpacker crowd. This is probably one of the most popular cities for backpackers in the entire United States.

Key West is a challenging destination for budget travelers and backpackers due to the higher prices. Key West is a pretty expensive destination, but there are Airbnbs and even a hostel or two that cater to budget backpackers.

Is Key West or New York City Better for Students?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for students. Also, Key West is not as famous, but is still a good town to visit for its student-friendly activities.

Many students frequent New York City. The city has a diverse population, and international students will feel right at home here exploring the city. There are also plenty of major universities including NYU, Columbia University, and Cornell University.

Key West is very popular with students. It's a great spring break destination with a quirky personality and many great activities.


Is Key West or New York City Better for Public Transit? Which Is Easier to Get Around Without a Car?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its public transit. However, Key West is a mediocre town for times when you don't have a car.

New York City has a great public transit system. The city has one of the largest subway systems in the world. There's also an elaborate bus system, ferry system, and yellow taxis all around town.

Public transit is quite limited in Key West. Public transportation in Key West is limited to a few buses.

Is Key West or New York City a more walkable city?

Key West
New York City

New York City is renowned for its high level of walkability. Also, Key West is not as famous, but is still a good town to visit for its ease of walking around.

It is easy to get around New York City on foot. The majority of the neighborhoods in Manhattan are very walkable and easy to explore on foot. Most people prefer not to drive here as it can be overwhelming and chaotic.

Key West is a somewhat walkable town. The town is the most walkable part of the Florida Keys. The area around Mallory Square and Duval Street is the most pedestrian friendly.

For even more information, also check out Is Key West Worth Visiting? and Is New York City Worth Visiting?.

Should I spend more time in New York City or Key West?

How long in Key West or New York City?

Both Key West and New York City have a number of activities to choose from. In our opinion, New York City has more to see and do, so we recommend spending more time in New York City than Key West. In general, 5-7 days is a good amount of time for Key West, and 3-7 days is enough time in New York City.

Families should spend more time in New York City than Key West. Because of the many family-friendly attractions and fun things to do for kids in New York City, it's a great place to visit with the whole family.

Couples should spend more time in New York City than Key West. You'll find plenty of romantic sights and fun activities in New York City that are perfect for a weekend getaway or a longer couple's trip.

Backpackers and budget travelers should spend more time in New York City than Key West if your budget allows for it. With a larger number of budget-friendly sights, good nightlife, and active things to do, anyone traveling on a budget would have a good time in New York City.


  • How many days in Key West or New York City? Ideal Length of Stay
    Key West 5-7 
    New York City 3-7

One day in Key West or New York City?

Many travelers enjoy the scuba diving and snorkeling and nightlife when visiting the lively destination of Key West. It's also a relaxing resort destination. Your budget might influence how long you stay. Since there is so much to do in the area, one day is probably not enough for all of it.

New York City is a big city with plenty to do. With so much to do, one day is probably not enough time to see everything. It will give you the chance to have new experiences.


A weekend in Key West or New York City?

It's hard to know how much time to spend in Key West. Make sure you visit the old town while you're here. It has many unique tourist attractions and fascinating things to do. A weekend is usually not enough time for a trip here as there is plenty to do.

New York City is a popular place that is full of things to see and experience. But since there are so many activities, you'll likely want to spend more than a weekend exploring. Take your pick from the many activities offered here.

Five days in Key West or New York City?

Many travelers enjoy the food and scuba diving and snorkeling when visiting the quaint destination of Key West. Travelers enjoy the resorts in the area as well. This town offers a variety of activities to choose from. If you have five days, this is a great place to go. Five days is usually enough time to experience most activities.

New York City is a popular choice for travelers. Five days here is typical. While some people choose to spend more or less time in New York City, five days is sufficent for most. The entire region has so many activities, and you'll want time to do everything.

A week in Key West or New York City?

Many travelers enjoy the scuba diving and snorkeling and nightlife when visiting the beautiful town of Key West. People often spend their time relaxing at one of the resorts. Plenty of people spend one week in the area when traveling.So, one week is just the right amount of time to spend here. The length of your ideal trip is an individual decision.

New York City is a great place to explore. It is common to spend one week here. One week is a great amount of time to relax and see the many things that New York City has to offer. This city offers something for everyone.


For some great organized tour ideas, see The Best 3-Week Tours in United States of America, The Best Bicycle Tours in United States of America, Tours for Outdoor and Nature Lovers in United States of America, and The Best Coach Bus Tours in United States of America.


Which place is cheaper, New York City or Key West?

These are the overall average travel costs for the two destinations.

The average daily cost (per person) in Key West is $551, while the average daily cost in New York City is $326. These costs include accommodation (assuming double occupancy, so the traveler is sharing the room), food, transportation, and entertainment. While every person is different, these costs are an average of past travelers in each destination. What follows is a categorical breakdown of travel costs for Key West and New York City in more detail.



Accommodation
  • Accommodation Hotel or hostel for one person
    Key West $132
    New York City $175
  • Accommodation Typical double-occupancy room
    Key West $264
    New York City $350
Compare Hotels in Key West and New York City

Looking for a hotel in Key West or New York City? Prices vary by location, date, season, and the level of luxury. See below for options and compare which is best for your budget and travel style.

Hotels in Key West


Hotels in New York City


Kayak helps you find the best prices for hotels, flights, and rental cars for destinations around the world. Compare prices for multiple destinations when planning your next trip.


Our Analysis
We've analyzed the average and typical hotel prices based on guest reviews, star ratings, and hotel amenities here: Key West Hotel Prices and New York City Hotel Prices.

Local Transportation
  • Local Transportation Taxis, local buses, subway, etc.
    Key West $51
    New York City $49
Typical Local Transportation Prices in Key West

Below are a few samples from actual travelers for transportation costs in Key West:


  • Rental Car for One Day
    $38

Hired Cars and Shuttles in Key West

Some specific examples of transportation prices in Key West:

  • Private Transfer from Key West hotels to Key West Cruise Port: $38
  • Private Transfer from Key West Int Airport to Key West Port: $38
  • Marathon/ Key Largo to Fort Lauderdale Airport(FLL) - Departure Private Transfer: $109
  • Key West to Key West Airport (EYW) - Departure Private Transfer: $57
  • Key West hotels to Key West Int Airport (EYW) Departure Transfer: $44
  • Key West Int Airport EYW to Key West Hotels Arrival Transfer: $44
  • Key West Int Airport (EYW) to Key West hotels Round-Trip Transfer: $87
  • Key West Int Airport (EYW) to Key West - Arrival Private Transfer: $57
  • Key West Airport (EYW) to Key West - Round-Trip Private Transfer: $114

Typical Local Transportation Prices in New York City

Some typical examples of transportation costs in New York City are as follows:


  • Subway
    $4.50
  • Taxi Ride
    $8.00
  • Subway
    $2.50

Hired Cars and Shuttles in New York City

Also for New York City, here are a few examples of actual transportation services:

  • Manhattan: Bus Transfer from/to Newark Airport: $21
  • New York: 1-Way Transfer to/from JFK & Grand Central Station: $27
  • Midtown/Lower Manhattan -JFK: Private Airport Departure Transfers: $29
  • Newark Liberty International Airport: One-Way Private Transfer to / from NYC: $34
  • Manhattan to EWR: One Way Shared Departure Transfer: $34
  • EWR to Manhattan: One Way Shared Arrival Transfer: $34
  • Manhattan to JFK: One Way Shared Departure Transfer : $34
  • JFK to Manhattan: One Way Shared Arrival Transfer : $34
  • LGA to Manhattan: One Way Shared Arrival Transfer: $34
  • Manhattan to LGA: One Way Shared Departure Transfer: $34
  • NYC: One-Way Shared Transfer to or from Newark Airport: $36
  • NYC: One-Way Transfer to/from JFK Airport and Manhattan: $36

Is it cheaper to fly into Key West or New York City?

Prices for flights to both New York City and Key West change regularly based on dates and travel demand. We suggest you find the best prices for your next trip on Kayak, because you can compare the cost of flights across multiple airlines for your prefered dates.





Food
  • Food Meals for one day
    Key West $385
    New York City $50

Food Tours and Cooking Classes in Key West

Also, here are some specific examples of food and dining related activities in Key West.

  • Sunset Dinner Cruise with Open Bar & Live Music: $81
  • Key West Sunset Cruise: Dinner and Drinks Included: $93
  • Southernmost Food & Cultural Walking Tour by Key West Food Tours: $93
  • Historic Seaport Food & Walking Tour by Key West Food Tours: $93
  • Old Town Secret Food Tour: $107
  • Key West Walking Food Tour With Secret Food Tours: $109
  • Key West Sunset Buffet Dinner Cruise with open bar and Live Music : $110
  • Sunset Sail Full Bar, Live Music & Dinner & Early Morning Snorkeling: $160
  • The Hemingway Experience by Key West Food Tours: $178
  • Dolphin Watching & Snorkeling in Key West with Sunset Dinner Cruise and Open Bar: $190
  • Snorkeling, Sunset Dinner Cruise & Open Bar: $200

Typical Food Prices in New York City

For New York City, here are some examples of average food and meal prices for travelers:


  • Gelato
    $7.50
  • Snacks for Two at Yankees Game
    $34
  • Coffee
    $6.53
  • Smoothie
    $6.95

Food Tours and Cooking Classes in New York City

For New York City, here are some samples of tours and activities related to meals and dining experiences:

  • New York, Queens Culinary Stroll : Food Tour on Foot: $23
  • Lower East Side and Essex Market Multicultural Food Tour: $39
  • Half-Day Private Pizza Crawl in Manhattan: $40
  • Shared Food Tour Bohemian Greenwichvillage: $45
  • NYC: Greenwich Village Guided Food Tour: $63
  • Greenwich Village NYC Pizza Walking Tour: $65
  • Pizza Walking Tour of Downtown Brooklyn: $65
  • Downtown Brooklyn Pizza Walking Tour: $65
  • East Village Pizza Walk: $65
  • East Village NYC Pizza Walking Tour: $65
  • Gastro Pub Pre/Post Theater Dinner in Times Square: $67
  • Chinatown New York Walking Food Tour: $70

Entertainment
  • Entertainment Entrance tickets, shows, etc.
    Key West $33
    New York City $180

Tours and Activities in Key West

Some specific costs of activities, tours, and entrance tickets for Key West are as follows:

  • Southernmost Ghosts Tour: $33
  • Adults only Sunset Cruise from Key West with Champagne: $81
  • Bahama Village Walking Tour: $30
  • Best of Key West Walking Tour with Glass Bottom Boat Cruise: $229
  • Best of Key West with Glass Bottom Boat Cruise: $294
  • Bike Key West Beaches and Back Roads Audio Tour: $11
  • Cruise Through Key West's Black History Audio Tour: $11
  • Dark Corners of Key West – Walking Tour: $350
  • Dark Corners of Key West Walking Tour: $180
  • Easy Stroll (or Bike) Through Downtown Key West Audio Tour: $11
  • Experience Key West Food Walking Tour: $113
  • Florida Keys Nature & History Tour from Key West: $94

Typical Entertainment Prices in New York City

Below are a few sample prices from actual travelers for New York City's activities, tours, and tickets:


  • Comedy Show Tickets
    $56
  • City Map
    $8.00
  • Broadway Musical
    $111
  • Broadway Show Program
    $10
  • Magazine
    $6.99

Tours and Activities in New York City

For New York City, here are a few prices for actual activities, tours, and tickets provided by various companies:

  • Central Park NYC: First Discovery Walk and Reading Tour: $3.20
  • Brooklyn Bridge Self-Guided Bike or Walking Tour Application: $5.00
  • Central Park: Self-guided Bike Tour App - Audio + Written: $5.00
  • Self Guided Central Park Bike or Walking Tour Application: $5.00
  • Private Audio Guided Walking Tour in New York: $5.45
  • Central Park Scavenger Hunt and Best Landmarks Self-Guided Tour: $6.51
  • Self Guided "Central Park Movie Tour" Solo Walking Tour in New York City: $6.75
  • NYC: Central Park Exploration Game and Tour: $6.93
  • Self-Guided Tour of the Museum at Eldridge Street: $7.50
  • Docent-Led Tour of the Museum at Eldridge Street: $7.50
  • New York City's Financial District: A Self-Guided Audio Tour: $7.99
  • NYC: Staten Island Museum Entrance Ticket: $8.00

For more ideas for your next trip, check out The Best Things to do in New York City with Kids, Things to Do in Central Park in NYC, and The Best Museums in New York City.


Alcohol
  • Alcohol Drinks for one day
    Key West $16
    New York City $29

Sample the Local Flavors in Key West

Also in Key West, these are the prices for nightlife and alcohol related activities from various tour providers:

  • Key West Haunted Pub Crawl Walking Tour: $30
  • Haunted Pub Crawl Walking Tour: $30
  • Key West Haunted Pub Crawl and Ghost Tour with Free T-Shirt: $32
  • Bone Island Haunted Pub Crawl: $32
  • 2.5-Hour Duval Street Pub Crawl: $43

Sample the Local Flavors in New York City

Some specific costs for nightlife related activities in New York City:

  • NYC West Village Pub Crawl: $21
  • New York Ghosts Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl: $34
  • NYC: Brooklyn Nightlife Pub Crawl: $34
  • New York: Boos and Booze Haunted Pub Crawl: $35
  • New York Rooftop Pub Crawl: $39
  • NYC: Manhattan's Only Whiskey Distillery Tour & Tasting: $42
  • Brooklyn Literary Pub Crawl: $49
  • Greenwich Village Literary Pub Crawl: $49
  • Little Italy Prohibition Pub Crawl: $64
  • East Village Gangster Ghost Pub Crawl: $64
  • Guided Brooklyn Craft Brewery Tour: $99
  • 1920s Schooner Sail with Wine Tasting: $139


When we compare the travel costs of actual travelers between Key West and New York City, we can see that Key West is more expensive. And not only is New York City much less expensive, but it is actually a significantly cheaper destination. So, traveling to New York City would let you spend less money overall. Or, you could decide to spend more money in New York City and be able to afford a more luxurious travel style by staying in nicer hotels, eating at more expensive restaurants, taking tours, and experiencing more activities. The same level of travel in Key West would naturally cost you much more money, so you would probably want to keep your budget a little tighter in Key West than you might in New York City.

If you're trying to decide if either of these two destinations are within your price range, also see Is Key West Expensive? and Is New York City Expensive?.


Which is Bigger, Key West or New York City?

New York City has a larger population, and is about 320 times larger than the population of Key West. When comparing the sizes of Key West and New York City, keep in mind that a larger population does not always imply the destination has more attractions or better activities. So, always research the type of place that you want to visit along with the activities and attractions that interest you.


When is the best time to visit Key West or New York City?

Both places have a temperate climate with four distinct seasons. As both cities are in the northern hemisphere, summer is in July and winter is in January.

Should I visit Key West or New York City in the Summer?

Both New York City and Key West during the summer are popular places to visit. Most visitors come to Key West for the beaches, snorkeling, the small town charm, and the family-friendly experiences during these months. Also, the summer months attract visitors to New York City because of the city activities, the music scene, and the family-friendly experiences.

In July, Key West is generally a little warmer than New York City. Daily temperatures in Key West average around 84°F (29°C), and New York City fluctuates around 77°F (25°C).

New York City gets a good bit of rain this time of year. Key West usually gets less rain in July than New York City. Key West gets 3.3 inches (83 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 4.5 inches (114 mm) of rain this time of the year.


  • Summer Average Temperatures July
    Key West 84°F (29°C) 
    New York City 77°F (25°C)

Should I visit Key West or New York City in the Autumn?

The autumn attracts plenty of travelers to both Key West and New York City. The autumn months attract visitors to Key West because of the shopping scene, the small town atmosphere, and the natural beauty of the area. Also, the city's sights and attractions, the shopping scene, the music scene, and the natural beauty of the area are the main draw to New York City this time of year.

Key West is much warmer than New York City in the autumn. The daily temperature in Key West averages around 80°F (27°C) in October, and New York City fluctuates around 57°F (14°C).

Key West gets a good bit of rain this time of year. In October, Key West usually receives more rain than New York City. Key West gets 5.1 inches (129 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.1 inches (78 mm) of rain each month for the autumn. The hurricane season in Key West is June to November.


  • Autumn Average Temperatures October
    Key West 80°F (27°C) 
    New York City 57°F (14°C)

Should I visit Key West or New York City in the Winter?

The winter brings many poeple to Key West as well as New York City. The shopping scene and the cuisine are the main draw to Key West this time of year. Also, many travelers come to New York City for the museums, the Christmas ambience, the shopping scene, the theater shows, and the cuisine.

Be prepared for some very cold days in New York City. In the winter, Key West is much warmer than New York City. Typically, the winter temperatures in Key West in January average around 70°F (21°C), and New York City averages at about 31°F (-1°C).

Key West usually gets less rain in January than New York City. Key West gets 1.7 inches (43 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.4 inches (86 mm) of rain this time of the year.


  • Winter Average Temperatures January
    Key West 70°F (21°C) 
    New York City 31°F (-1°C)

Should I visit Key West or New York City in the Spring?

Both New York City and Key West are popular destinations to visit in the spring with plenty of activities. Many travelers come to Key West for the beaches, the small town charm, and the natural beauty. Also, many visitors come to New York City in the spring for the activities around the city and the natural beauty.

In April, Key West is generally much warmer than New York City. Daily temperatures in Key West average around 77°F (25°C), and New York City fluctuates around 52°F (11°C).

In April, Key West usually receives less rain than New York City. Key West gets 0.8 inches (21 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.8 inches (98 mm) of rain each month for the spring. June to November is the hurricane season in Key West.


  • Spring Average Temperatures April
    Key West 77°F (25°C) 
    New York City 52°F (11°C)

Typical Weather for New York City and Key West

Key West New York City
Temp (°C) Rain (mm) Temp (°C) Rain (mm)
Jan 70°F (21°C) 1.7 inches (43 mm) 31°F (-1°C) 3.4 inches (86 mm)
Feb 71°F (21°C) 1.4 inches (36 mm) 33°F (1°C) 3 inches (77 mm)
Mar 74°F (23°C) 1.7 inches (42 mm) 42°F (6°C) 3.9 inches (98 mm)
Apr 77°F (25°C) 0.8 inches (21 mm) 52°F (11°C) 3.8 inches (98 mm)
May 81°F (27°C) 2.7 inches (68 mm) 63°F (17°C) 4.1 inches (105 mm)
Jun 83°F (28°C) 4.5 inches (114 mm) 72°F (22°C) 3.2 inches (82 mm)
Jul 84°F (29°C) 3.3 inches (83 mm) 77°F (25°C) 4.5 inches (114 mm)
Aug 84°F (29°C) 3.9 inches (98 mm) 76°F (24°C) 3.9 inches (99 mm)
Sep 83°F (29°C) 5.7 inches (144 mm) 68°F (20°C) 3.7 inches (93 mm)
Oct 80°F (27°C) 5.1 inches (129 mm) 57°F (14°C) 3.1 inches (78 mm)
Nov 76°F (24°C) 2 inches (50 mm) 47°F (8°C) 3.9 inches (99 mm)
Dec 72°F (22°C) 1.4 inches (35 mm) 36°F (2°C) 3.4 inches (88 mm)