A Travel Price Comparison for United States of America Martha's Vineyard vs. New York City for Attractions, Food, Nightlife, and Couples

Should you visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Which is cheaper to visit? Which is more expensive for vacation?

Which city should you visit? Read on to compare the activities as well as the prices of travel for Martha's Vineyard and New York City. We'll break down costs for accommodation, food, transportation and more to help you learn more about these two destinations. Then, you can figure out if either of these two places are accessible based on your travel budget, schedule, and interests. So, let's dig into it.

Martha's Vineyard

Martha's Vineyard is a peaceful, affluent, and coastal island. It offers plenty of small town charm along with sights and activities, too. This is also a very beautiful destination which attracts plenty of visitors. Other reasons to visit include beaches, hiking, and shopping.

New York City

New York City is a energetic, cosmopolitan, and one-of-a-kind city. Visitors will also find so much to do here because it's a large city with many sights and attractions. It offers plenty of beauty for visitors. It's also popular because of the theater, nightlife, and live music.

Martha's Vineyard and New York City: Pros and Cons

Is there more to do in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Visitors will usually find more to do in New York City than Martha's Vineyard, as it offers more sights, attractions, and activities. New York City is better known for its museums, theatre productions, food, nightlife, music, shopping, christmas markets, and big city activities, while Martha's Vineyard is more popular for its resorts, beaches, hiking, small town charm, and impressive beauty. New York City is more touristy than Martha's Vineyard and is known for its high-reaching skyscrapers, iconic landmarks, world-class theater scene, and endless energy. Also, New York City is famous for The Statue of Liberty. Martha's Vineyard is well known for its natural beauty, charming New England towns, and upscale local shopping.

How is Martha's Vineyard different from New York City?

Which is Better for a Holiday?

Let's take a look at the differences and similarities between New York City and Martha's Vineyard. Then, you can decide for yourself which place is better for your next trip.

Are the Museums and Historical Sights Better in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its historical sights. However, Martha's Vineyard is not known for its sights and museums.

With plenty of landmarks, attractions, and museums, New York City has many famous sights for visitors. The sights and museums around the city are too numerous to list, but some of the most famous include the Statue of Liberty, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Museum of Modern Art, Central Park, and the Empire State Building. This is a city that is filled with iconic landmarks and you could spend weeks here and still not see it all.

Martha's Vineyard offers a handful of options for museums and historical sights. There are a couple of local museums in the area as well as the Martha's Vineyard Museum.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Theater?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its shows and theatre. However, Martha's Vineyard is not a theatre destination.

New York City is considered to be a world-class theater destination. Visiting Broadway is a quintessential NYC experience. Whether you enjoy the theater or simply want to experience something new, seeing a Broadway show is a true bucket list activity.

Martha's Vineyard is not a theatre destination.

Is the Food Better in Martha's Vineyard or New York City? Which Destination has the Best Restaurants?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its local flavors and cuisine. Also, Martha's Vineyard is not as popular, but is still a nice island for its local cuisine and restaurants.

Eat your way through New York City, as it has many local or world renowned restaurants to choose from. The city has a diverse variety of restaurants, with everything from local dives to Michelin star options. There are many neighborhoods that are notable for their ethnic cuisine, particularly Little Italy and Chinatown. Quintessential NYC dishes include NYC pizza, NYC hot dogs, bagels, and Chinese dim sum.

With its innovative style combined with traditional elements, Martha's Vineyard makes for a great culinary experience. The region prioritizes sustainable agriculture and there are many local eateries that range from upscale to more casual. You'll find the greatest number of options during the peak summer months, but regardless of when you visit, you're sure to eat well.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Nightlife?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its evening party scene. However, Martha's Vineyard is not known for nightlife.

New York City has a colorful and one-of-a-kind nightlife scene. Known as the city that never sleeps, you can be assured that NYC has some of the best nightlife in the world. There are world class bars and clubs, but also local venues that have a more relaxed atmosphere. Several famous clubs include Paul's Cocktail Lounge, Le Bain, and Avant Gardner.

Most people don't head to Martha's Vineyard specifically for the nightlife scene, but you can find a few options. There's more of a laid back vibe, but the best towns in the evening are Edgartown and Oak Bluffs.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Music?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its music scene. However, Martha's Vineyard is not a live music destination.

New York City has become a mecca for musicians from around the world. Popular music venues include Music Hall of Williamsburg, Radio City Music Hall, Beacon Theatre, and Forest Hills Stadium.

Martha's Vineyard is not a live music destination.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Resorts?

Martha's Vineyard is a must-visit destination for its luxury resorts. However, New York City is not a resort destination.

Vacationers flock to Martha's Vineyard for its luxury resorts. There are beautiful and luxurious resorts that attract celebrities and socialites. Many have pools and serene outdoor spaces that you can enjoy.

New York City is not a resort destination.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Beaches?

Martha's Vineyard is an excellent place to visit for its beaches. However, New York City is not a beach destination.

Many people visit Martha's Vineyard for it's beautiful beaches. The beaches are scenic and peaceful. Head to northern side of the island for shallow water, or south for more surf. While there are some public beaches that are open to everyone, there are also beaches that require a parking or town beach permit to visit.

New York City is not a beach destination.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Hiking?

Martha's Vineyard is a good destination for its hiking trails. However, New York City is not a hiking destination.

Martha's Vineyard offers some nice hiking trails. There are miles of trails around the island that pass through fields or along the coastline. The island is mostly flat, so the hikes are relatively easy for all skill levels.

New York City is not a hiking destination.

Is the Shopping Better in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its shopping areas. Also, Martha's Vineyard is not as popular, but is still a nice island for shopping.

Many people travel to New York City specifically to go shopping. The shopping is as diverse as the city itself. Head for Fifth Avenue for high end shopping or check out any of the many street markets for local items. New York is known for its many flea markets where you can find vintage items at a good price. And if you're looking to pick up a souvenir shirt or knick knack, there are plenty of souvenir shops around town as well.

Martha's Vineyard is an extremely popular place for shoppers. There are no malls, so you'll enjoy shopping at local stores that sell a mix of locally made items and name brand. There are many art galleries as well as craft festivals during the summer months.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Christmas?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its Christmas holiday experiences. However, Martha's Vineyard does not offer Christmas activities.

People travel from all around to experience the Christmas season in New York City. Christmas in the city is a quintessential experience. From the Christmas tree and ice skating at Rockefeller Center to seeing a live performance of the Nutcracker, everyone enjoys the holidays in New York.

Martha's Vineyard does not offer Christmas activities.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Christmas Markets?

New York City is a great city for visiting Christmas markets. However, Martha's Vineyard does not offer Christmas markets.

The Christmas markets in New York City offer plenty to see during the holidays. There are a number of Christmas markets that pop up around town during the holiday season. Nothing will get you more in the holiday spirit than wandering these unique venues.

Martha's Vineyard does not offer Christmas markets.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Families?

New York City is a great city for its kid-friendly activities. Also, Martha's Vineyard is not as popular, but is still a nice island for its family-friendly activities.

You'll find plenty of family-friendly things to do in New York City. The city has many activities for kids of all ages including world class museums, beautifully designed playgrounds, and theater shows designed just for young ones. There are many kid-friendly restaurants as well and older kids will enjoy visiting the iconic landmarks in this world-class city.

Martha's Vineyard is a family-friendly place to visit. You can visit local farms or go to a local baseball game. There's also cafes, ice cream shops, and donut shops that kids will enjoy.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Couples?

Martha's Vineyard and New York City both terrific destinations for a couple.

Martha's Vineyard is fantastic couple's destination with fun and romantic activities. It's filled with charming bed and breakfasts and plenty of New England charm. Couples will enjoy the quaint restaurants and mix of history, small town charm, and outdoor adventure.

New York City makes for a terrific place to visit as a couple. From a beautiful carriage ride through Central Park, to a romantic river cruise at night, there is an endless list of unique activities that couples can enjoy in the city. Whether you're interested in theater, the arts, music, or nightlife, this city has it all.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Backpackers and Budget Travelers?

New York City is a great city for backpackers and budget travelers. However, Martha's Vineyard is not known for backpackers.

Plenty of budget travelers and backpackers visit New York City. It isn't a particularly budget-friendly destination, but it does get its share of backpackers, so you'll find a nice list of hostels and affordable hangouts that are perfect for the backpacker crowd. This is probably one of the most popular cities for backpackers in the entire United States.

Martha's Vineyard is not the best destination for backpackers and budget travelers due to its high prices. Budget options are limited, making this an inconvenient destination for backpackers.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Students?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its student-friendly activities. However, Martha's Vineyard is not popular with students.

New York City is a very popular place to visit for students. The city has a diverse population, and international students will feel right at home here exploring the city. There are also plenty of major universities including NYU, Columbia University, and Cornell University.

Martha's Vineyard is not popular with students.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City Better for Public Transit? Which Is Easier to Get Around Without a Car?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for times when you don't have a car. However, Martha's Vineyard is not known for its public transit.

Public transit in New York City is top-notch. The city has one of the largest subway systems in the world. There's also an elaborate bus system, ferry system, and yellow taxis all around town.

Public transit is generally limited in Martha's Vineyard. Access to the island is limited to boat and air. There's a bus service that connects the towns.

Is Martha's Vineyard or New York City a more walkable city?

New York City is an amazing city to visit for its ease of walking around. Also, Martha's Vineyard is not as popular, but is still a nice island for its walkability.

New York City is a very easy city to get around on foot. The majority of the neighborhoods in Manhattan are very walkable and easy to explore on foot. Most people prefer not to drive here as it can be overwhelming and chaotic.

Martha's Vineyard is somewhat walkable. Many of the towns have walkable downtown areas, but traveling between towns and into the countryside requires a vehicle.

For even more information, also check out Is Martha's Vineyard Worth Visiting? and Is New York City Worth Visiting?.

Should I spend more time in New York City or Martha's Vineyard?

How long in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Both Martha's Vineyard and New York City have a number of activities to choose from. With generally more activities and things to do, visitors tend to spend more time in New York City than in Martha's Vineyard. Usually, 1-3 days is a good amount of time for Martha's Vineyard, and 3-7 days is enough time in New York City.

Families should spend more time in New York City than Martha's Vineyard. Because of the many family-friendly attractions and fun things to do for kids in New York City, it's a great place to visit with the whole family.

Couples should spend more time in New York City than Martha's Vineyard. You'll find plenty of romantic sights and fun activities in New York City that are perfect for a weekend getaway or a longer couple's trip.

Backpackers and budget travelers should spend more time in New York City than Martha's Vineyard if your budget allows for it. With a larger number of budget-friendly sights, good nightlife, and active things to do, anyone traveling on a budget would have a good time in New York City.

One day in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Even though Martha's Vineyard is a small town, it has plenty of activities to choose from. It's also a relaxing resort destination. Your budget might influence how long you stay. If you enjoy all that's offered here, then one day is just the right amount of time to spend here.

When visiting New York City, people usually allow for lots of time. Since there is so much to do in the area, one day is probably not enough for all of it. It offers something for everyone.

A weekend in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

It's hard to know how much time to spend in Martha's Vineyard. Most people come for the beaches. It has many unique tourist attractions and fascinating things to do. For many, it makes a great getaway for a weekend. A weekend is usually enough time to experience most activities.

When visiting New York City, people usually allow for lots of time. Your budget might influence how long you stay. A weekend is usually not enough time for a trip here as there is plenty to do.

Five days in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Martha's Vineyard is a small town, so it's a great destination if you're short on time. Travelers enjoy the resorts in the area as well. This island offers a variety of activities to choose from. Five days is usually plenty of time to spend here with extra days to spare. With this much time, visitors often visit nearby destinations or take day trips.

When visiting New York City, people usually allow for lots of time. If you have five days, this city makes for a great vacation. It has many unique tourist attractions and fascinating things to do. With all of its activities, you can easily fill five days here.

A week in Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Martha's Vineyard is a small town, so you can explore the area with less time. People often spend their time relaxing at one of the resorts. One week is more than enough time to enjoy everything. Take some day trips to nearby places to fill the extra days. The length of your ideal trip is an individual decision.

New York City is a popular choice for travelers. This city offers a variety of activities to choose from. One week here is typical. This would be the perfect place to spend one week, as it has just the right amount of activities.

For some great organized tour ideas, see The Best 2-Week Tours from New York City, The Best 2-Week Tours from Anchorage, The Best 2-Week Tours from San Francisco, and The Best 2-Week Tours from Los Angeles.

When we compare the travel costs of actual travelers between Martha's Vineyard and New York City, we can see that New York City is more expensive. And not only is Martha's Vineyard much less expensive, but it is actually a significantly cheaper destination. So, traveling to Martha's Vineyard would let you spend less money overall. Or, you could decide to spend more money in Martha's Vineyard and be able to afford a more luxurious travel style by staying in nicer hotels, eating at more expensive restaurants, taking tours, and experiencing more activities. The same level of travel in New York City would naturally cost you much more money, so you would probably want to keep your budget a little tighter in New York City than you might in Martha's Vineyard.

If you're trying to decide if either of these two destinations are within your price range, also see Is Martha's Vineyard Expensive? and Is New York City Expensive?.

When is the best time to visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City?

Both destinations experience a temperate climate with four distinct seasons. And since both cities are in the northern hemisphere, summer is in July and winter is in January.

Should I visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City in the Summer?

The summer attracts plenty of travelers to both Martha's Vineyard and New York City. The summer months attract visitors to Martha's Vineyard because of the beaches, the hiking, the small town charm, and the family-friendly experiences. Furthermore, the city activities, the music scene, and the family-friendly experiences are the main draw to New York City this time of year.

In the summer, Martha's Vineyard is around the same temperature as New York City. Typically, the summer temperatures in Martha's Vineyard in July average around 73°F (23°C), and New York City averages at about 77°F (25°C).

New York City receives a lot of rain in the summer. In July, Martha's Vineyard usually receives less rain than New York City. Martha's Vineyard gets 2.8 inches (72 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 4.5 inches (114 mm) of rain each month for the summer.

Should I visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City in the Autumn?

The autumn brings many poeple to Martha's Vineyard as well as New York City. The hiking trails, the shopping scene, the small town atmosphere, and the natural beauty of the area are the main draw to Martha's Vineyard this time of year. Additionally, many travelers come to New York City for the city's sights and attractions, the shopping scene, the music scene, and the natural beauty of the area.

In October, Martha's Vineyard is generally cooler than New York City. Daily temperatures in Martha's Vineyard average around 53°F (12°C), and New York City fluctuates around 57°F (14°C).

Martha's Vineyard usually gets around the same amount of rain in October as New York City. Martha's Vineyard gets 3.3 inches (83 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.1 inches (78 mm) of rain this time of the year.

Should I visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City in the Winter?

Both New York City and Martha's Vineyard are popular destinations to visit in the winter with plenty of activities. Many travelers come to Martha's Vineyard for the museums, the shopping scene, and the cuisine. Also, many visitors come to New York City in the winter for the museums, the Christmas ambience, the shopping scene, the theater shows, and the cuisine.

New York City can get quite cold in the winter. Be prepared for some very cold days in Martha's Vineyard. Martha's Vineyard is much colder than New York City in the winter. The daily temperature in Martha's Vineyard averages around 28°F (-2°C) in January, and New York City fluctuates around 31°F (-1°C).

In January, Martha's Vineyard usually receives around the same amount of rain as New York City. Martha's Vineyard gets 3.5 inches (89 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.4 inches (86 mm) of rain each month for the winter.

Should I visit Martha's Vineyard or New York City in the Spring?

Both New York City and Martha's Vineyard during the spring are popular places to visit. Many visitors come to Martha's Vineyard in the spring for the beaches, the small town charm, and the natural beauty. Also, most visitors come to New York City for the activities around the city and the natural beauty during these months.

In the spring, Martha's Vineyard is cooler than New York City. Typically, the spring temperatures in Martha's Vineyard in April average around 48°F (9°C), and New York City averages at about 52°F (11°C).

Martha's Vineyard usually gets around the same amount of rain in April as New York City. Martha's Vineyard gets 3.7 inches (94 mm) of rain, while New York City receives 3.8 inches (98 mm) of rain this time of the year.

Typical Weather for New York City and Martha's Vineyard